Interesting and insightful facts about freebie subscribers vs. buyers

In my email yesterday, I made the claim:

“[People who get on your list by buying from you right away] are on average 3.3X MORE LIKELY TO BUY subsequent offers than ‘freebie’ subscribers who never bought anything previously.”

Nobody challenged me on that claim, though it is very challengeable.

“Really? 3.3x precisely? Why not 3.4X? Or .33x? Or 33x?”

I didn’t just pull this number out of Narnia. I actually went in search of data. And I found data, explicitly supporting this claim. If you like, I’ll tell you about it, because it’s genuinely interesting and insightful:

Earlier this year, a funnel-building Sheila named Kate McKibbin ran an actual side-by-side test on the matter. Over the course of 90 days, she had similar numbers of leads go through a lead magnet funnel and a direct sales funnel.

The lead magnet funnel consisted of a lead magnet, an email sequence, and a low-ticket offer. The direct sales funnel drove leads direct to the same low-ticket offer.

How would the two funnels compare?

The lead magnet funnel had 1,200 people go through it and get on the email list. The direct sales funnel had 1,100 people go through it and get on the email list.

The ad spend for the lead magnet funnel was $4,288. The ad spend for the direct sales funnel was… $50k.

“Whoa!” you might say. “Who’s got 50k to drop on ads over 90 days?”

Well, it wasn’t really $50k out of pocket. This particular direct sales funnel ended up having a return on ad spend in excess of 2x. In other words, much of that $50k was really recycled initial investment, which was simply being rolled over to get new subscribers.

Because of this, the results of the front-end sales were that:

The lead magnet funnel recouped about 60% of ad spend (in other words, it resulted in a $1,700 loss). On the other hand, the direct sales funnel made a $57,000 profit.

But ok. Not every direct sales funnel makes 2x ad spend on day zero, and such profit/loss numbers will vary wildly across different funnels. Whatever. The point I want to get to, and the the genuinely interesting and insightful thing, was what happened on the back end.

McKibbin tracked how many subscribers, coming from each funnel, ended up buying her back-end offers over 90 days.

At the end of 90 days, lead magnet leads bought an additional 15 of McKibbin’s offers. On the other hand, direct sales leads bought 50 additional offers.

If you take 50 (the additional sales from the direct sales funnel) and divide it by 15 (the additional sales from the lead magnet funnel) you get 3.3, or rather, 3.33333333333333333333…

So there you go. That’s where my claim that people who get on your list by buying are 3.3x more likely to buy down the line rather than freebie subscribers.

As for McKibbin, she points out that, while the results of the direct sales funnel were way better ($50k profit on day zero plus a bunch more back end sales), that doesn’t mean the lead magnet funnel is bad or broken.

60% of ad costs recouped on the front end, plus 15 additional sales over 90 days, can reasonably put you in profit at the end of those 90 days, or even sooner. She concludes:

“The lead magnet funnel isn’t slower because it’s broken. It’s slower because it’s lower risk.”

About that:

Wouldn’t it be nice to get the low risk of the lead magnet funnel… while at the same time getting the front-end profits and 3.3x better subscribers of the direct sales funnel?

That “best of both worlds” option is what Nick Bandy and I are currently offering you. For more info:

https://www.skool.com/daily-email-house/would-you-bid-1-for-a-magical-super-subscriber-vending-machine