Yesterday, I read a fantastic yet true story, a kind of real-life Lord of the Flies. Except the outcome was very different from the book:
As you might know, Lord of the Flies is a story about a bunch of boys who get shipwrecked on an island.
Pretty soon, they become mean, thuggish, and destructive. Some of the boys are killed by the others. Half the island is burned down.
What can you do? People are savages, and kids even more so. Except maybe not:
The real-life version of this story involves six boys from the island kingdom of Tonga.
They were bored stiff at their English boarding school.
So they decided to steal a local fisherman’s boat and sail away to adventure, and maybe even make it to New Zealand.
They didn’t make it.
After months of search, the boys were declared dead back home. Funerals were held for them.
And then, 15 months later, they were discovered by an Australian adventurer fishing in the waters around an uninhabited island named ‘Ata. The boys had shiprecked there and survived, alone all that time.
And here’s the real-life twist:
All six boys were happy, healthy, and harmonious.
They had survived by eating fish and coconuts and drinking rainwater collected in hollowed-out tree trunks.
They had broken up their chores, such as gardening, cooking, and guard duty, and they took turns doing them.
They built a gym and a badminton court, and they played a makeshift guitar made out of the wreckage of the boat.
When one of the boys fell down a ravine and broke his leg, the others climbed down after him, brought him back up, then set his leg using sticks and leaves. He recovered while the other boys took turns doing his chores.
So is this really the true nature of human beings?
And if so, why does your typical junior high school look nothing like it?
Why does Lord of the Flies resonate with us instead?
The answer comes from another real-life variant of the Lord of the Flies theme. A bunch of people stranded on an uninhabited island… with a TV crew and a prize to be won.
I’m talking about the TV show Survivor. I’ve never watched it, but I know the basic setup:
Direct competition for something scarce.
It’s all you need to turn people into savages. A finding that’s been repeated in different settings, not just on reality TV.
So let me leave off today by saying I can see two options:
One is to disconnect as much as possible from the doctrine of healthy competition. This might require moving to a deserted island, or at least turning off the TV.
The other option is not to disconnect from anything, but to profit from it. Because creating scarcity, even when there is none, and encouraging competition, or at least reminding people of it, is a great means of control.
Marinate on that for a bit. And if you want more real-life stories on the topic of profit and control, you might like my email newsletter. But better be quick, because spots are limited and others are taking them as you read this. Click here to sign up.